The black and white is way to go, Love the composition and details. Well done.

I like the composition very much.

Excellent mood and composition!
BW is definitely the only way to go here!
Title suits well the end result.
Could possibly have just a tiny bit more space below the bycycle.

oh man, when i saw the b&w i thought....YESSS! but then i saw the color and love it too. i usually will pick b/w over color but for me the colors here are rustic and dense and fit the scene i vote COLOR. like moserArtist said...give it a slight CW rotation and you have it. nice...!

• claudia

I prefer the color one!.....but the B&W is also beautiful!!
Wonderful mood!!....very nice composition!
Well done Erdi!
Carlos

Great shot! I like them both equally. The B&W has an older feel to it while the colored is more "modern." Nice job! Really great detail.

Good work. I like the color version more. Love the composition and textures. +8

great work! love the b&w! the coloured one is good too, but the window on the right side, has a bright feel that is a little different from the overall tone mood, just a matter of personal preference. +9

I prefer the black and white version, very nice
Still it looks a little dark here, but that could also be my monitor
Beautiful work Eraldo!

I prefer the BW, but the colored version is nice to! very good composition! and good choice of HDR! excellent details! I love the high contrast!

my tops!
Greets Lenny.

Good work
I like the color one best.
Top Mark

Well, personal taste, I prefer BW like moser ...
Good lighting and details, yes, definately more space below the bycicle would work
Great work +10

what an amzing fantastic outstanding work lol

The composition is great. The colour and b&w both work for me - no real preference.
Don

I enjoy them both. Excellent composition. Well done Erdi!
John

hm i like the colored one more but i love em both =D

nice one erdi!

Hi Eraldo, nice one indeed. Just like Claudia I vote for the colored version. For the same reason. So you see, apparently both versions are "KUHL"

Great pic! I like the BW, but I prefer the colored version.

Black & white for me !! Very well done !!
Love this one as it is ! But if you were still looking for improvements !!
Maybe you can experiment with correcting it for lense distortion !! Not sure if it will help.. But give it a shot !
Since the shot has so many lines making them exactly parallel to the border will make it look even better.

I like the color one better. The colors play off the composition and each other well, which breathes life and character into the image more than the B/W one, imo. A little nitpicking, but that branch poking in from the side must die, lol.

9/9